|  |  | | Customer Reviews: | | | Average Customer Review: Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
Poor Effort Mar 12, 2010 Do you ever read someone's writing and can tell you would enjoy someone's personality? Well, let me start by writing: I like James Brady. He is a former Korean War, combat Marine and seems a very likeable fellow. I have read articles before, where he has tackled war and Marine historical topics with proper reverence and authority, while providing an entertaining read. This isn't one of those projects.
The premise of this book is aimed at recovering the experiences of combat Marines, while asking for the reasons why Marines are so effective at combat. A little self serving? Perhaps, but most of us former Marines revel in this stuff and, besides, the reputation of the Corps is well cemented in history and lore. So why was the outcome of this endeavor less than fruitful? Brady gave a mere fraction of an effort.
James Brady, passed on providing the untold combat stories of the common Marine. The deep, personal reflections that exist by the hundreds of thousands. Instead,Brady gave us trite, superficial interviews with his pals and all of the famous former Marines he could dredge up. Sure, there are a few stories that were worth reading, but they only scratch the surface. They were wedged between glib interviews of every former Marine, socialite Brady could suck up to. Really. This read like an Oprah interview made at tea time in the Hamptons.
Absolute rubbish.
1 of 1 found the following review helpful:
Why Jim Brady wrote this book Jul 01, 2009 I certainly don't know why he wrote this book, for Brady never actually systematically tried to answer the question posed in his title Why Marines Fight. Some of the individual stories of men he interviewed were very good, but they get buried amid references to Brady himself and the continual name dropping. Supposedly Brady had a wealth of material as Marines in droves responded with letters to him when they heard about the proposed title to the book. Expecting to read the stories of unknown Marines, I was disappointed when so much of the book covered the stories of Marines turned famous politician such as James Webb and John Warner of Virginia and the late John Chaffee of Rhode Island. Whether that was Brady's choice or those of his editor, I wish far more space had been given to the stories of lesser known Marine and no space at all to John Warner's penchant for dating beautiful and filthy rich women. An ever greater waste of space are the political comments on events in Iraq and Afghanistan scattered throughout the book on a random basis. These opinions bear no relevance to Brady's purported topic and show no special insight on Brady's behalf. They merely echo the conventional wisdom of Brady's peers on the celebrity journalist beat at Parade magazine.
WHY MARINES FIGHT Jan 19, 2009 I WOULD RECOMMEND THIS BOOK FOR ANY PERSON, BUT ESPECIALLY FOR ALL MARINES,THE ONLY PROBLEM IS THAT MOST OF THE MARINES WHERE OFFICERS AND WE ALL KNOW THE HEART OF THE MARINE CORPS IS THE ENLISTED GRUNT.SEMPER FI
Why Marines Fight a Hit with 14-year-old Future Marine Dec 25, 2008 My son has dreamed of being a Marine for the past two years. As a member of the Young Marine Corps, he eats, breathes and sleeps the discipline and principles he will need to be a good soldier. I'd had some concerns that he wanted to be a Marine for the wrong reasons, so I purchased this book to let him know that I accept and honor him for wanting to defend his country, but that the reasons he had once given for his desire to join the Marine Corps were a little off base. During our early Christmas party, he spent a long time flipping through the color photos and reading. He was very excited and entranced by the narrative.
I didn't get to read the book, myself, but glanced at the pages as he flipped through them. The photos are thought-provoking and realistic, and the pages have a layout that will keep a young person reading. "Why Marines Fight" is an excellent gift for any Marine -- past, present, or future -- and for anyone who cares about them.
2 of 3 found the following review helpful:
Fascinating Read Mar 22, 2008 I was interviewed for this book and while it may come across as a bit self-serving, I thought the overall concept was great and the other, cross-generational stories very interesting. I could see where some people might disagree with the running commentaries, but I thought it kept the stories flowing well.
|
|  |
|