|  |  | | Customer Reviews: | | | Average Customer Review: Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
Well researched, well written insights into boys becoming men Nov 11, 2009 Bravo Peg Tyre. This book has given me quite a bit to ponder. Are we leaving a generation of boys behind and what can we as parents do to address this?
Peg Tyre has a beautifully researched and written book explaining the whys, hows, and whats of this very disturbing trend.
You MUST read this book..... Sep 19, 2009 As a mum who has just begun to enjoy seeing her young son (age 5) start Kindergarten, I wanted to be more informed about the challenges ahead regarding his school life/education. I was a high school teacher for 10 years in the UK/Hong Kong and had already noticed issues with the differences between how girls and boys learn/are treated in school. Having read many reviews about this and a few other books, I settled upon this one first.
So far, I'm about half way through this book and am fully engrossed in it. The author has done satisfying research in my opinion, and is making me very aware of the current situation re. schools and how boys are being taught. I'm looking forward to getting it finished and have already plugged the book to many friends of mine who have boys.
I recommend this book to parents (of boys AND girls), teachers and anyone who thinks that there isn't a problem within the educational system when it comes to the success of our young males.
Good Starting Point, Not the Last Word Sep 12, 2009 The Trouble with Boys is a book I would highly recommend to any parent of a young boy. As a father of a 16 month old, reading this book has prepared me to be much more selective in choosing a preschool for my son (when the time comes). But more importantly this book has shown me that I might have to fight for my little boy to assure he is not punished for being male. Too many bad grades are giving to little scholars in the making for messy handwriting, assertive behavior, and being loud, active and goofy! And after reading this book I know I'll have to keep a watchful eye on my son's teachers and the environment they create for him at school.
However, this book is really just the opening salvo in what must be a deeper research into all the ways the world has changed for little boys over the past 40 yrs. A larger look into all the ways the social upheavals of the 1960's and 1970's have effected the male middle class would be interested and I think would shed more light onto the learning gap between boys and girls AND between boys today and boys in the early 1960's.
Overall, highly recommended reading.
2 of 2 found the following review helpful:
From a Teacher, To a Teacher Aug 23, 2009 I am a second grade public school teacher, and this book really changed my attitude about the "problem boys" in my class. I've gained an understanding that has made me feel more confident about teaching difficult boys, more responsive to their personalities, and less alone in my struggle. The book investigates the trouble with boys from sociological, cultural, psychological, and neuropsychological perspectives.
If you are a skeptic, read this book. I grew up with 2 sisters listening to "Free to Be You and Me" and graduated from Vassar College, a school very focused on women's issues. That boys are at some sort of educational disadvantage is the last thing I would have ever thought of (even though the ratio at Vassar was 60/40 women to men when I attended). I have no brothers, no sons, and I had no experience with young boys when I began teaching 5 years ago. Boys were a shock to my system. I wish I had read this book back then.
A warning: Peg Tyre tries hard to cater the book to teachers as well as parents, but it is clear that she sees a battle between parents and teachers of rowdy boys, and she sides with parents. There is one distasteful message to teachers at the end of the book (stating that teachers better love the irritating behaviors boys tend to exhibit, or else leave the profession)... but hopefully by then Tyre has gotten you to buy into the idea that there IS a problem and that we DO need to take responsibility for it and make a change...so hopefully you can take the statement as constructive criticism.
*It is also important to read this book if you have read the bogus book The Minds of Boys (by Michael Gurian). Once chapter in Tyre's book helps clear up ridiculous ideas that Gurian (who has NO background in science) has created about "teaching to boy brains."
Overall, a really important topic for teachers to be familiar with, and a good book to read.
Peg Tyre's "The Trouble with Boys". Jul 17, 2009 The Trouble with Boys: A Surprising Report Card on Our Sons, Their Problems at School, and What Parents and Educators Must Do
As a teacher in a boys' school and researcher into boys' education I found Peg Tyre's book a good starting point for those who are new to the field. Once the grammatical, syntactical and spelling mistakes are laid aside, the central argument of Tyre's book is easily digested. How relevant her work is for readers outside the U.S. is a moot point, but given that most of the English-speaking world seems hell-bent on repeating America's mistakes, Tyre's book is probably a foretaste of the future.
|
|  |
|