Average Customer Review: Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
A Cold Affair Turns Hot May 31, 2009 **Spoiler Alert**
Isabelle Huppert plays Dominique, a rich, educated, career woman. One night she meets Quentin, played by Vincent Martinez. Quentin isn't exactly a hustler-more of a bi-sexual rent boy. Quentin and Dominique get on in a curious way. Dominique is icy cold and seems more than happy with a casual arrangement. Quentin is young and needs entertainments all over town. But as Dominique delves into Quentin's life she discovers she feels both a parental protection and lovers attachment. Quentin courts Dominique's best friend's daughter and announces his intention to wed. Furious, Dominique obtains compromising photographs of Quentin. When Quentin asks "Aren't I entitled to a normal life?", Dominique acquieses. Then Quentin decides he doesn't want to walk away if Dominique is willing to let him go. Dominique pushes him out of the nest anyway but years later discovers that Quentin's "normal" life wasn't the dream he had anticipated. Their "unnormal" love was actually fulfilling in comparison and probably something they should have held on to.
The French are so...inventive when it comes to relationships. Their love stories never cease to intrique me. They're so realistic and cynical when it comes to love that they have no problems with completely letting go and letting love rule their lives. The School of Flesh is based on gay Japanese authour Yukio Mishima's short story by the same name, but the French have aptly adapted it to express their cultural take on love. (The School of Flesh was never translated into english and therefore not available on amazon.)
This is the third film I've seen with Isabelle Huppert and she has grown on me to the point of adoration. Her characters are always icy cold and able to handle eveything and she plays the parts to perfection. I highly recommend watching her in Story of Women and The Piano Teacher (Unrated Edition).
4 of 4 found the following review helpful:
Long Live Queen Isabelle! Nov 08, 2003 Isabelle Huppert is like one of those stars whose luminence never dims. She dominates every scene she steps into. And those characters she plays. Always strong women, who beneath their steely exteriors hide a million wounds. You never know where you will end up with her. In confusion. In a rage. In tears.The School of Flesh is no exception. It is all Huppert's feast with some tasty side-dishes as well. In it, she plays a confident and self-possessed doyen of the fashion industry, Dominque, who childless and partnerless, longs for somebody to love. While out with her girlfriend, they end up in a gay bar where Dominique's eyes rest upon the sexy bartender, Quentin(Vincent Martinez). Her gaze is surprisingly returned. In fact, the hunted soon turns on the hunter. Encouraged, Dominque, like a moth to the flame, returns to the source of her desire. Things start to roll and before she knows it, Quentin has moved in. With her invitation of course. A seemingly harmless arrangement. Dominique gets a sexy young lover, while Quentin gets financial and emotional security. But is there any real love between the two......or is it just a relationship of strict economics....need meeting need? Dominique begins to scratch the surface of her live-in lover's past and soon finds shaky ground. A fatherless family, an impoverished childhood, a prostitutional present and most of all, a disturbing emotional emptiness . Quentin uses sex to pay the bills and keep himself distanced from any true commitment, while Dominique is prepared to suffer any humiliation in order to keep her bed-treasure. She evens suffers the ultimate humiliation when Quentin elopes with a younger woman. But Dominique's needs overpower her dignity. She soons spirals down into emotional collapse, while Quentin's vanity blinds him. Oblivious to the pain he is causing, he misses out on the chance for real love. Dominque gives him everything and he appreciates none of it. School of Flesh is a cautionary tale about what happens when we seek to satisfy our desperate need for love and security at all costs. Even at the cost of dignity. This film coldly dissects the workings of a dependent relationship. The last scene when the ex-lovers meet anew is one of the best I've ever seen. Especially for those of us who've been there. Heartwrenching, you don't want to end like that, but deep down, you know it has to. As a modern fable, this film works. Sometimes though, it moves too quick with too much material......lots of little detours....Quentin's mother, fellow hustler friends, 'clients,' none of which really add anything to the story. Just there to tease you a bit. Or annoy. And confuse. But the film is kept on track by its trinity of characters. Huppert's intensity is the glue that holds it all together. Without it, the film would be all flash and lust. Martinez' laissez faire attitude and macho studliness provides the right contrast to Huppert's vulnerability. The third pillar, Chris, the bar-owning transvestite, intrigues with his oracle-like knowledge of Quentin's past. There's a subtle edge to him as if he were jealous of Dominque's treasure. A common past with Quentin is hinted at, but never developed. Overlooking these minor defects, School of Flesh is well worth sitting through, pondering over and experiencing. For Huppert fans and those in destructive relationships, it is a must see!
10 of 10 found the following review helpful:
Deliciously Forbidden Jan 27, 2001 ''L'Ecole de la Chair'' (School of Flesh), a candidly modern take on the search for intimacy, is the basis for a sensuous, sexy, and painfully passionate love affair between an older woman and a younger man. Dominique (Isabelle Huppert), a career-minded, well-off older woman meets Quentin (Vincent Martinez), a young street hustler with a mysterious background. From the start, and in spite of herself, Dominique responds to Quentin's obvious signs of interest, and they strike up a ''deal'': an affair, with no strings attached. Watch as these two beautifully sad beings duel for control and fight to entrap one another. Do they have a chance at love? I'll never tell! A subtle yet powerful movie, with characters you'll never forget. Quintessentially French in many ways, this is a fabulous dramatization of Yukio Mishima's Japanese novel (roughly translated as ''School of Love''), adapted to modern-day France. ''The School of Flesh'' will not be liked by everyone, of course, but if you're looking for a quiet, painstaking anatomy of the intricacies of heterosexual love, especially of the May-December variety, this is the movie for you. Buy it TODAY! This is a difficult DVD to locate. For movies that explore a similar topic with various settings and characters, also check out these movies: Indochine, Un Coeur en Hiver (A Heart in Winter), Nettoyage à sec (Dry Cleaning), Entre Nous (also with Isabelle Huppert).
6 of 11 found the following review helpful:
Huh? Aug 09, 2000 First let me say that I am happy to see a movie for once that has an older woman falling for a younger man (such a rarity!). However, it seemed so sappy. Why is it that the older woman named Dominique, played by Isablelle Huppert, has to look so desperate to have a man to the point that she becomes completely dependent on her live-in lover, Quentin, and has him move into her apartment almost immediately after meeting him. In other movies, you never see the older man becaming a parasite to his young girlfriend, and tending to her every need like in this movie. This was obvious a movie written and directed by a man!
7 of 7 found the following review helpful:
Intoxicating Jul 04, 2000 Isabelle Huppert and Vincent Martinez are superbly cast as victims of co-dependence. School of Flesh inverts the older-man young-woman theme and flavors it with contemporary nuances. Here we have an affluent older woman who gets off on the power money afford her, and a younger ambitious young man who prostitutes himself in more ways than one. This is no doubt a moral tale, though thankfully the director allows the viewer to make up his own mind about who abuses and who is abused, who is good and who is bad. The final scene is devastating, perhaps the best I've seen of films in this genre. Also, Isabelle Huppert is stunning--you may fall in love with her.
|