|  |  | | Customer Reviews: | | | Average Customer Review: Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
2 of 2 found the following review helpful:
Still scratching my head Jan 01, 2009 There are several things I cannot grasp about this. First-why not either: write the book anonymously if you were going to lie so blatantly, or write is as a fiction/reality 'interwoven' type story? Why BRAZENLY have interviews and photos splashed in the NY Times?? Did this person actually think no one from her past was going to come forward and identify her? I've seen footage of her being interviewed in her old 'hood'-and all I could conclude is that this person would do anything for attention. How sad that she lied to the publishing company for so many years!
How bizarre to go so far as to have pictures of fake dead relatives hanging in your home to show the interviewer from the Times? And be raising pitt bulls to further the ruse? And put your daughters photo in the paper? What is wrong with this person? It's a shame because the book was interesting, but I could not give it a good review because it is not a memoir of any sort.
5 of 6 found the following review helpful:
Actually Fairly Hilarious That Dec 30, 2008 anyone including the publisher would think that the premise of white girl being raised by poor blacks was true. My God where are they from?
1 of 3 found the following review helpful:
Why a memoir? Fiction sells too... Oct 15, 2008 I saw this at the library and picked it up, not knowing about all the publicity, which I'm surprised I didn't know, since I try to keep abreast of all things literary. Anyway, I did have some doubts about the foster care system placing her in that home, and why they would; about how she was able to stay in that home and never be removed despite Big Mom's struggle with caring for all of these foster kids (which I didn't understand, since she got money for them); that the lady in the gray suit would be taking her to visit someone in juvenile hall (she didn't have anything else to do?); and how she seemed to effortlessly blend in with the Bloods in the park and they treat her like she's one of them. I also was disappointed with not learning how she fared in college. She touched on it a bit but not enough considering how challenging it must have been.
Anyway, it could have been fiction if she did a little bit more research to make it flow and I'm mad that it was faked. What is up with everyone faking their life stories?
6 of 6 found the following review helpful:
The Power of Imagination Aug 15, 2008 This book, billed as a truthful memoir of the life of a white girl raised by a black family in the South Central LA ghetto, is not factual, but is in fact the product of "Margaret B. Jones's" very febrile imagination. For starters: White children are not placed in black foster homes; the author claimed to be of mixed American Indian - White, but not a drop of the former made it into her face; that the first thing she did with the money from her first drug sale was buy a cemetery plot; that she had graduated from the University of Oregon, and the list goes on. Was the purpose to determine how naïve the reader, and more importantly, professional reviewers are of the true conditions in the ghetto?
Lessons abound. Clearly all too many professional reviewers do not read critically, and are prone to "groupthink." Why do so many reviewers, all at the same time, think a book like "Love and Consequences" is significant; worthy of a review, and not a single ONE detects anything amiss, when virtually everything is. Why must the reading public rely on a truthful sister to reveal the true facts?
Should the average reader mourn the curtailment of book review sections in major newspapers? Clearly a better solution may be reading rationale and thoughtful reviews posted at Amazon. With the prevalence of these incidents in the publishing industry, it stands to reason that more exist, waiting to be found.
0 of 3 found the following review helpful:
Still a good read May 27, 2008 I didn't know the book was fiction until I went to review it. I'm disappointed that the author couldn't be honest about this, but the story is still good. I have a sister who lives in the Bakersfield area, who raised two African American children in grinding poverty in a very bad neighborhood. There are many things about the story that rang true from what she has told me. The question for me: does the story move us forward? I think it does. I feel more compassion for poor people and the circumstances that lead them to crime and the gang life. Maybe I'm naive, but I think that's a good thing despite the deception by the author.
|
|  |
|