|  | | | Customer Reviews: | | | Average Customer Review:
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
0 of 2 found the following review helpful:
 I Need This Recording Aug 13, 2007
I got this from the library this past spring. It was a rare case of absolute love at first measure. This strange and wondrous concerto cannot help but fascinate, and the ever-astounding Hilary Hahn gives a performance that I feel sure would meet with Samuel Barber's approval and highest admiration.
... Furthermore, if I do not get this for my birthday I will most certainly run down the street screaming like a bad Wagner soprano.
3 of 5 found the following review helpful:
 The Barber is a classic, the Meyer is forgettable crossover piffle Jan 10, 2007
It's a bit shocking that almost every reviewer here equates these two works. The Barber concerto has become a classic, with four or five major recordings since it returned to popularity thanks to Gil Shaham's DG recording that paired it with the even more lush, ar more neglected Korngold concerto. The Meyer work has no chance of reaching such a status. It is quasi-minimalist piffle with overtones of Copland, bluegrass, and anonyous folksiness. I heard Play the work--she is its dedicatee--with the Boston Sym., and I was embarrassed for the musicians. Asking a major symphony orchestra to play a work whose challenges wouldn't frighten a junior high band was shameful.
But Sony has commerical savvy on its side. Hahn sells better than almost anyone except Joshua Bell, and they wanted to attract the same audience that Meyer pleas3ed with his Appalachian Journey CD and other crossover bestsellers with Yo-Yo Ma and Bell. Even so, his attempt at Philip glass For Dummies strikes me as quite poor, and even Hahan's charismatic presence can't salvage it. Thank goodness for the Barber, a lovely account that belong with the best, especially because Ms. Hahn plays the Presto finale as fast as lightning. By comparison everyone else seem to be dawdling.
3 of 6 found the following review helpful:
Meyer and Hahn Score Big Jul 06, 2006
I first heard this piece (the Meyer concerto) on the radio about a month and a half ago and was so immediately struck by it that I ordered my own copy right then and there. I can't believe that this recording has not received more air play and is so little known. But then I notice that a lot of fine recent compositions don't receive much attention.
I have been aware of Hahn for a few years now, but was not especially impressed with her. Her recording of the Brahms concerto, which I ordered at the same time, confirms my impression that she was a capable but not yet mature musician at the time she recorded it.
However, I must say that the Meyer piece suits her right down to the ground and she responds to it with everything she's got, and it turns out to be quite a lot. She is of course immaculately precise with not a wrong note. But that's the minimum we expect of professionals. What impresses is the range of moods and energies that she encompasses here, and fearlessly too. She alternately sweet, gay, introspective, and ferocious, as the composition demands. Meyer wrote this piece expressly for her, beginning when she was only 16 and completing it three years later, and I think he read his subject well.
This is a virtuoso piece and technically demanding. But it is not merely showy. Everything in it is there for a solid musical reason, and it works on that level as well. It is a well balanced work. Although the soloist is front and center though virtually the entire performance, the orchestra is not relegated to the role of mere spear carriers. There is a true dialogue between the soloist and the members of the orchestra, both individually and tutti. And the St. Paul Chamber Orchestra performs extremely well here.
My all time favorite violin concertos are the Brahms, Sibelius, Beethoven, and Tchaikovsky in more or less that order. Whether the Meyer belongs in that august company it is much too soon to say. Perhaps not. It will be interesting to see if other soloists take it up, and if so, what they make of it. But I must confess to a present infatuation with it. I played this recording six times in the first two days I had it. You must understand that this is something I never do. I generally make it a practice not to listen to a piece more than once a day so as not to make it stale. An exceptional recording I might listen to twice in a day. But I could not seem to get enough of the Meyer-Hahn collaboration here. You go, Girl!
4 of 5 found the following review helpful:
A personal but thoughtful pairing of Concerti Jun 08, 2006
You all know Hilary. This purchase for me was going back to her late childhood after enjoing the Mozart recently. This album is personal because Meyer wrote the work commisioned for her, as Hilary notes (and I liked to see her write the notes for this recording). Never fear Mr. Meyer. You may better know him as a daddy bass player. But he plays keyboard and strings as well, so he has good grounding for arrangement of this nice little composition. Definitely more modern, it is a bit of Delius' melodic summer, but with the tinge of fall (it is a small matter but the fall treatment of the album is appropriate). This is not earthshaking composition, but it is intelligent, honest, competent and quite enjoyable.
But the Barber is what you came for, and that Mr. Wolff and Ms. Hahn deliver. The orchestra is technically perfect in timing and tone, and perfectly balanced to the violin. No child left here, we get Barber as he would have hoped for so long ago.
2 of 4 found the following review helpful:
Fantastic recording Feb 21, 2006
Sound quality is fabulous, and Hahn's playing is very impressive. I didn't realize what a gem this Barber Concerto was until I found this cd.
|
| | |
