|  |  | | Customer Reviews: | | | Average Customer Review: Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
laughable Mar 15, 2010 i dont know what this is but its not punk rock. its like mashing perfect circle together with my chemical romance. gross... afi has no fire inside as far as i can tell
sad.... Jan 11, 2010 I was a fan.... I can usually go along for the ride when a band changes their sound, even if that change is huge. I did it with Rush in the 80s, Paradise Lost in the 90s, Theatre Of Tragedy in the 00s, etc. But this album coming from a once cool punk outfit is just cringe worthy. There is no edge of any kind, its not punk, horror-punk, goth, or even rock, just radio friendly pop... meh.
Decent album but no real standout tracks... Jan 09, 2010 I've only listened to this album a few times, so maybe it will grow on me... Some of the songs are a little too poppy for my taste, although I wouldn't say there is a "bad" song on this album. There also aren't any "great" songs, no epic choruses, eerie melodies, or any of the things that make "Sing the Sorrow" a classic. However, as a whole, it is still an album worth buying, and for the most part it still sounds like AFI. If you're still hoping for AFI to go back to making generic punk rock, don't buy this album. You will be highly disappointed.
GREAT! Jan 07, 2010 I am incredibly happy with this purchase! The price was GREAT for what I got when I pre-ordered it! Although it is not AFI's best work, it is still great. The bonus songs are the best in my opinion.
1 of 3 found the following review helpful:
Seriously? Dec 10, 2009 I have listened to this band for years. I grew up punk rock, and what AFI provided in the mid to late nineties was exceptional. I would be preaching to the choir if I went on about how good Black Sails was. Not being naive, we also know how all music begins to evolve, especially for a band who "strikes it big", but this album; this disaster of an album, is nothing short of awful.
What else is there to really say. As a fan, I couldn't be more disappointed. Their once thoughtful and poetic lyrics provoked creativity and an amazing ability to relate to Davey and their originality. This album doesn't provoke anything but to turn on MTV, and relate to other radio friendly bands like three doors down. But at least AFI is touring with Nickleback this winter. Someone else said this before me, and I couldn't put it better any other way.."I quit AFI"
|
|  |
|